
Structured Literacy Reading
Understanding Structured Literacy and the New Zealand context
Understanding the Science of Reading
The Science of Reading is a body of research about how we learn to read. This research illustrates for us that reading comprehension is a product of both word recognition and language comprehension.
The science of Reading teaches us that reading comprehension is made up of two key strands – word recognition and comprehension. In New Zealand we use the Gough and Tunmer Simple View of Reading (1986) and the Scarborough Reading Rope (Hollis Scarborough) to understand and explain the essential components of Both the Science of Reading and The Structured literacy approach for instruction.
Both research and evidence-based methodologies are based on teaching two key elements of the reading process
The word recognition strand focuses on accurately and efficiently recognising words
For word recognition students need phonological awareness, decoding and sight word recognition skills, strategies and knowledge.
The language comprehension strand focuses on understanding and gaining meaning from text
For language comprehension students need skills, strategies and knowledge of background knowledge, vocabulary, language structures, verbal reasoning and literacy knowledge.
Implications for teachers
•Learning about the Science behind structured literacy
•Deeply understand the research and evidence supporting the word recognition and language comprehension strands of the process of reading
•Understanding the interconnectedness and complexity of the two strands of reading and using these as a road map for instruction
•Learning what all teachers need to be able to know and be able to do to effectively and equitably teach students to read and write and use oral language proficiently, and to improve literacy achievement for all students.
•Using structured literacy approaches and pedagogies when teaching both word recognition and teaching language comprehension.
Understanding the how of Structured Literacy
Structured literacy instruction is explicit, systematic, cumulative and diagnostic/responsive.
Teaching is Explicit
Explicit instruction is instruction that is deliberate, unambiguous, clear cut and direct. For instruction to be explicit it must focus on critical and essential content (skills /strategies / knowledge). This content is made clear to students by:
•Beginning lessons with learning goals and outcomes – supported by formative assessment practices of feedback, self-assessment, self-reflection
•Clear, concise and consistent use of teacher language and terminology to support student learning
•Includes explicit teacher demonstration and think alouds, a high level of teacher-student interaction and provides multiple opportunities for guided and supported student practice
•Includes examples and non-examples to build student understanding
•Includes instruction that is multi-sensory strategies to involve the visual, auditory, and tactile/kinesthetic senses in learning to improve memory
•Explicit instruction is viewed as the core of effective teaching and learning – and this involves embedding the following key learning strategies within instruction – spaced practice, retrieval practice, interleaving, elaboration, concrete examples, dual coding
Teaching is Systematic
Taking a systematic and sequential approach to teaching and learning enables our learners to understand and practice according to a scope and sequence. Teaching that is systematic and sequential follows a clear scope and sequence that moves students from skills already mastered to new more complex ones. With systematic instruction students practice each new learning to automaticity – eg Ready to Read phonics plus scope and sequence and the revised English in New Zealand Curriculum.
Systematic delivery of instruction connects students with what was learned – so that new learning becomes automatic and links to development of learner metacognition – before they learn the next skill/concept. Additionally, this approach to instruction builds strong student self-efficacy and motivation towards learning.
Teaching is Cumulative
Automaticity is also linked to cumulative practice and ongoing review. In cumulative teaching new knowledge is consolidated and leads to further learning, when each step is based on concepts previously learned. Cumulative teaching includes starting lessons with a review of past learning structure in such a way that this review provides “building blocks” for further learning and connects knowledge building from one step to the next. In practice, this means that daily review in preparation for next steps learning, and long-term review (weekly and monthly) are important components in building automaticity, makes learning “stick” (stickability) and develops long term memory.
Teaching is Diagnostic and Responsive
Diagnostic assessment helps teachers to know and understand the student’s strengths, needs and knowledge level in preparation for instruction. This assessment provides clarity of what needs to be taught and informs teaching approaches taken (dose and density of learning). Diagnostic assessment investigates student learning and understanding in order to provide explicit knowledge of what students know and don’t know - and the next steps for student learning - SEE, NOTICE, and practice. This assessment enables teachers to be best positioned to build a specific needs-based learning pathway for their students.
Examples of formal assessment tools to support structured literacy in New Zealand include DIBELS, Adaptive Bryant pseudo word tool, AsTTle reading and writing, along with specific tools such as record of oral language. Informal assessments – including the well-known practices of formative assessment - are also used regularly within a structured literacy approach to monitor progress and achievement towards learning goals.
When following a structured literacy approach teachers regularly build assessments of word recognition, decoding and spelling into regular instruction to make sure individual needs of students are being met.
Understanding the WHAT of the language comprehension strand
• Background knowledge
• Wide vocabulary and strategies to work out words
• The ability to understand, to reason (verbal reasoning) with and engage with text
• Language structures of Syntax (knowledge of grammar, sentence structure) and Semantics (text structure, sentence, paragraph and text meaning)
• Literacy knowledge – different genres are read differently
Understanding the what of Structured Literacy
Structured literacy is grounded in the Science of Learning and the Science of Reading and Writing. It is an approach for teaching oral and written language skills in an explicit and systematic manner.
Understanding the WHAT of the word recognition strand
• Phonological awareness, the ability to recognise (hear and listen to) and use/manipulate the spoken sounds of written language – the sound system of language. The skills are done orally – listening to and producing sounds. Spending time producing and isolating phonemes (smallest unit of sound) – progressing from beginning to final to middle sounds, blending and segmenting sounds (blending – putting sounds together – and segmenting – saying a word and then segmenting in to individual sounds and manipulating sounds – swap sounds within a spoken word – swapping beginning, middle and end sounds bat – sat – bat – bit – bat - ban
• Developing skills of phonological knowledge, phonemic awareness, alphabetic principle (the phonics code), orthographical knowledge, morphology and knowledge, to develop decoding and word recognition skills
• Lexical - Word recognition – recognising high utility non-decodable words, high frequency words and sight words -
Selection and Use of High-Quality text for instruction
For those students requiring additional support with the word recognition strand high quality decodable texts – eg the Ready to Read Phonics Plus series – and the associated Scope and Sequence – are recommended
Additionally, throughout structured literacy instruction, students should be supported as they work with many kinds of texts—stories, informational text, poetry, drama, and so forth, even if that text is read aloud to students who cannot yet read it independently. Reading worthwhile texts that stimulate deep thinking is a critical component of Structured Literacy (source fact sheet – Structured literacy – International Dyslexia Association, with thanks to Lousia Moats, 2020).